Or come eat in at

205 NE Commercial Circle

Keystone Heights, FL 32656

We like this place, the food is authentic Italian and is very good, and flavorful, with generous portions. An enthusiastic, polite, friendly , family  run this little restaurant . The large calzone is giant and the pizza is the bomb. Lasagna and eggplant are there if you need a change. I highly recommend this restaurant. Tell them we sent you.

Bill W., Gainesville FL


To Order… (352) 478-8140

(352) 478-8140

Open 7 Days - Mon-Sat 11 AM to 9 PM  Sun Noon to 9PM

Keystone Heights History

Born in Brooklyn, New York, Nick Tonetti was raised on Long Island finishing up his New York life style in the small city of Oneonta, New York. Nick got his Italian Restaurant training in many small mom and pop restaurants honing his skills to become the accomplished chef that he is today.

In December of 2006, Nick decided to move to sunny Florida, packed up and chose Lake City to open his first Brooklyn Boys Pizza Restaurant. After several years and locations Nick met his beautiful wife, Karen, fell head over heels for her, and she convinced him to move to the beautiful town of Keystone Heights. After opening a small take out only location in 2014, Brooklyn Boys Pizza Restaurant has flourished and expanded to a comfortable full service restaurant for all to enjoy.........